This is a meeting of the Regulatory Committee of Hampshire County Council held on the 15th Nov 2023.
The last meeting of the Regulatory Committee was on the 17th Apr 2024, and the next meeting will be 15th May 2024.
Ashburton Hall - HCC
Item | Title | Minutes |
1 | Apologies for absence |
Apologies were received from Councillor Chris Donnelly. Councillor Stephen Philpott attended as a deputy. |
2 | Declarations of interest |
Members were mindful that where they believed they had a Disclosable Pecuniary Interest in any matter considered at the meeting they must declare that interest at the time of the relevant debate and, having regard to the circumstances described in Part 3, Paragraph 1.5 of the County Council's Members' Code of Conduct, leave the meeting while the matter was discussed, save for exercising any right to speak in accordance with Paragraph 1.6 of the Code. Furthermore Members were mindful that where they believed they had a Non-Pecuniary interest in a matter being considered at the meeting they considered whether such interest should be declared, and having regard to Part 5, Paragraph 5 of the Code, considered whether it was appropriate to leave the meeting whilst the matter was discussed, save for exercising any right to speak in accordance with the Code. |
3 | Minutes of previous meeting |
Minutes of Previous Meeting
It was noted that there was some duplication in the attendance list, but the minutes of the last meeting were then agreed. |
4 | Deputations |
The Chairman confirmed that seven deputations had been received for the meeting along with one County Councillor. |
5 | Chairman's Announcements |
The Committee was reminded of upcoming training sessions and informed that previous training slides and recordings could be viewed on the Members Regulatory Toolkit. |
6 | Ecogen Recycling Limited, Kings Worthy |
Report and Appendix A (Conditions)
Appendix B Committee Plan Appendix C Appendix D - Existing HGV route Appendix E - Highway mitigation locations on Existing HGV route Appendix E2 - Stoke Charity Road at railway overbridge Appendix E3 - Loveden Lane at disused railway overbridge Appendix F - Nearest Residential Properties and Monitoring Locations Appendix E1 - Stoke Charity Road south of and at the Ecogen site access road junction Revised Application -
Variation of condition 7 (volume of waste) and 13 (HGV Movements)
of Planning Permission 19/00200/HCS at Ecogen Recycling Limited,
Stoke Charity Road, Kings Worthy, Hampshire SO21 2RP (No.
23/01338/HCS) WR240
The lead officer summarised the
report, highlighting the update report that had been published (see
minute book). This covered some amendments to the original report
and further information received since the publication, but did not
affect the recommendations. As detailed in the report, the
applicant had taken some proactive measures in response to local
concerns (including the installation of signage for HGV’s
upon exiting). The site has been actively monitored and no formal
complaints have been received by the Waste Planning Authority since
the last planning application was heard.
The Committee received seven deputations on this item along with the County Councillor. Local residents Amanda Hassell, Rosamund McCarthy, Ann Edwards and Steve Waters all attended and spoke against the application along with Councillor Signe Biddle from Kings Worthy Parish Council and Councllor Steve Cramoysan from Winchester City Council. The applicant attended to speak in support of the proposals and County Councillor Jackie Porter also shared her concerns regarding the application and potential impact on the local area.
During questions of deputations, the following points were clarified:
During questions of the officers, the following points were clarified:
During debate, Members agreed that attendance of Highways
officers would have been helpful for the meeting due to most of the
issues being around HGV’s and the road adjoining the site.
Whilst the Committee empathised with the local residents, it was
also acknowledged that a previous lapsed application for the site
had included no vehicle restrictions, which set a precedent. Some
Members had concerns regarding the creep of vehicle permissions and
emissions and road damage as a result of HGV’s, whereas
others noted that the HGV’s using the road were from other
sites as well as the applicant and so not all responsibility fell
to the site specifically. The scheme shall cover freight management measures (including the maintenance and retention of Heavy Good Vehicle (HGV) routing and speed limit signage along the haul road), management of HGVs queuing prior to site opening) and the communication of measures to all HGV drivers entering and departing the site. The scheme shall be implemented as approved for the duration of the development. Reason: To ensure the satisfactory use of the highway in accordance with Policy 12 (Highway impacts) of the Hampshire Minerals & Waste Plan (2013). This a pre-commencement condition which relates to the use of the highway and therefore goes to the heart of the permission.” This was supported by 14
Members of the Committee and therefore approved. The recommendation
as amended was then put to the vote. a) The conditions listed in Appendix A b) The completion of legal agreements to ensure that the required mitigatory works to the public highway are completed to ensure levels of road safety are maintained along the Heavy Goods Vehicle (HGV) route between the site’s vehicular access with Stoke Charity Road and at the agreed locations along Stoke Charity Road and Lovedon Lane c) The update report
d)
The amendment supported by Committee as
follows: The scheme shall cover freight management measures (including the maintenance and retention of Heavy Good Vehicle (HGV) routing and speed limit signage along the haul road), management of HGVs queuing prior to site opening) and the communication of measures to all HGV drivers entering and departing the site. The scheme shall be implemented as approved for the duration of the development.
Voting
|
Whitehill & Bordon Community Party
Not required
Liberal Democrat
Present, as expected
Liberal Democrat
Present, as expected
Liberal Democrat
Present, as expected
Liberal Democrat
Not required
Liberal Democrat
Not required
Labour
Not required
Labour
Not required
Labour
Present, as expected
Independent
Not required
Independent
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Apologies, sent representative
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as expected
Conservative
Present, as substitute
Conservative
Not required
Conservative
Present, as expected
None
Expected
17th Apr 2024 Regulatory Committee
20th Mar 2024 Regulatory Committee
21st Feb 2024 Regulatory Committee (Cancelled)
24th Jan 2024 Regulatory Committee
13th Dec 2023 Regulatory Committee
15th Nov 2023 Regulatory Committee
18th Oct 2023 Regulatory Committee
13th Sep 2023 Regulatory Committee
19th Jul 2023 Regulatory Committee
22nd Jun 2023 Regulatory Committee (Cancelled)
15th May 2024 Regulatory Committee
12th Jun 2024 Regulatory Committee
17th Jul 2024 Regulatory Committee
18th Sep 2024 Regulatory Committee
16th Oct 2024 Regulatory Committee
13th Nov 2024 Regulatory Committee
11th Dec 2024 Regulatory Committee
16th Jan 2025 Regulatory Committee
19th Feb 2025 Regulatory Committee
19th Mar 2025 Regulatory Committee